Best Pie Irons for Camping 2024: Ultimate Guide to Campfire Delicacies
Are you a camping enthusiast who loves a good old-fashioned pie over a campfire? If so, you’re in the right place. Welcome to our guide on the best pie irons for camping in 2024. This is the perfect read for those who enjoy the blend of adventure and gastronomy. Don’t worry, we’re not talking about wrestling bears for honey or foraging for berries. We’re talking about a culinary gadget that will take your campfire cooking to the next level.
Camping trips are all about bonding, sharing stories, and creating unforgettable memories. We all know that nothing brings people together quite like food. And what could be better than a warm, delicious pie, filled with your favorite ingredients, cooked over a crackling campfire? Well, that’s an experience the best pie iron can provide. And let’s be honest; there’s something wildly satisfying about making your own food in the wilderness, even if it’s just a humble pie.
Choosing the right pie iron can be a game-changer for your camping trips. A pie iron is not just a tool; it’s the key to a world of creative campfire cuisine. It can transform simple ingredients into mouth-watering meals. Whether you’re a fan of a savory steak and cheese pie or have a sweet tooth for apple cinnamon pies, the right pie iron will make you the gourmet chef of the great outdoors.
So, sit back, relax, and let us guide you to the best pie irons for camping in 2024. Get ready to elevate your camping experience and impress your fellow campers with your culinary wizardry. And hey, who knows? You might even bear-proof your campsite with the irresistible aroma of your pies.
Our Picks:
- Rome Industries 1705 Pie Iron Sandwich Cooker
- Field & Stream Square Pie Iron
- Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker
- Texsport Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Square Pie Iron
- Rome’s Round Pie Iron
What Are the Best Pie Irons for Camping?
When it comes to choosing the right pie iron for your camping trips, there are a few things to consider. It’s not just about picking the first shiny gadget you see. It’s about understanding what makes a good pie iron and how it can transform your camping culinary experience.
The first thing to consider is the material of the pie iron. The majority of pie irons are made from cast iron or aluminum. Cast iron is a great heat conductor and gives your pies a nice, even cook. However, they are a bit heavy, which might require you to flex those muscles a bit more. On the other hand, aluminum pie irons are lighter and easier to handle but might not give your pies that golden-brown finish. So, you’ll need to decide what’s more important to you – a perfect pie or an easier hike?
Secondly, you need to think about the design of the pie iron. Some pie irons have a long handle, which keeps your hands away from the heat. Others have a double-sided design, which is perfect for cooking pies evenly, but might require a bit more skill to flip without spilling the contents. And let’s not forget about the shape – round or square? This can be a tough decision, especially if you’re a perfectionist who likes your pies to look as good as they taste.
Finally, remember that the best pie iron is the one that works for you. It’s the one that makes your camping trips more enjoyable and your pies more delicious. It’s the one that becomes a trusted companion on your outdoor adventures and a legendary figure in your campfire cooking tales. So, arm yourself with knowledge, take your time, and choose wisely. Because the right pie iron can make the difference between a good camping trip and a great one.
1. Rome Industries 1705 Pie Iron Sandwich Cooker
The Rome Industries 1705 Pie Iron Sandwich Cooker stands tall among its peers. As a product of Rome Industries, a renowned brand in the world of camping cookware, it’s a top contender when it comes to the best pie irons for camping in 2024. This pie iron exudes quality from every angle and is designed to make your camping culinary experience a memorable one.
Diving deeper into its features, the Rome Industries 1705 Pie Iron Sandwich Cooker is a classic square pie iron, perfect for toasting sandwiches or grilling burgers. It’s designed with an extra-long handle to keep your hands safe from the heat. The pie iron opens up like a book, making it easy to place your bread and filling, and close it up tight for a perfect toast.
Specifications:
- Blade Material: Cast Iron
- Handle Material: Wood
- Weight: 3.15 pounds
Tested Features:
- Cast iron construction ensures even heating and excellent heat retention.
- Long handle with wooden grip keeps hands at a safe distance from the fire.
- Easy to clean and maintain.
| Pros | Cons |
| – Durable construction – Excellent heat retention – Easy to use and clean | – Slightly heavy due to cast iron construction |
2. Field & Stream Square Pie Iron
Next on our list is the Field & Stream Square Pie Iron. This pie iron is a versatile cooking tool that will help you whip up delicious pies, sandwiches, and more over a campfire. The Field & Stream Square Pie Iron is a testament to the brand’s commitment to quality, durability, and practical design.
Featuring a square design, this pie iron is perfect for making sandwiches or toasting bread. It’s made of durable cast iron, ensuring even heat distribution and excellent heat retention. The handles are made of wood and are long enough to ensure your hands are safe from the fire. Furthermore, this pie iron is easy to clean, ensuring a hassle-free experience even in the great outdoors.
Specifications:
- Blade Material: Cast Iron
- Handle Material: Wood
- Weight: 3.5 pounds
Tested Features:
- Cast iron construction for even and thorough cooking.
- Long wooden handle for safe handling.
- Easy to clean and maintain.
| Pros | Cons |
| – Durable and sturdy construction – Excellent heat distribution and retention – Safe and easy to use | – It might be a bit heavy for some users due to its cast iron construction |
3. Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker
If versatility is what you’re after, then the Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker is a great pick. Coghlan’s is a brand known for its quality camping gear, and this pie iron is no exception. It’s a handy tool that allows you to cook a variety of meals, from sandwiches to pies, and even meat or vegetables.
The Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker is designed with a unique double-clamp system that holds your food in place while cooking, ensuring an even toast and a mess-free experience. The two-part hinge design makes it easy to open and close while the long handle keeps your hands safe from the heat. Made of heavy cast iron, it ensures even heat distribution and is built to last.
Specifications:
- Blade Material: Cast Iron
- Handle Material: Wood
- Weight: 3.07 pounds
Tested Features:
- Unique double-clamp system for secure cooking.
- Two-part hinge design for easy use.
- Durable cast iron construction for even cooking.
| Pros | Cons |
| – Versatile and easy to use – Durable and sturdy construction – Unique double-clamp system for secure cooking | – The hinge might be stiff when new and require some breaking in |
4. Texsport Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Square Pie Iron
The Texsport Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Square Pie Iron is a great option for those looking for a ready-to-use pie iron. As the name suggests, it comes pre-seasoned, saving you the time and effort of seasoning it yourself. This pie iron from Texsport, a reliable brand in the camping gear industry, is designed to deliver excellent performance and durability.
With a square design, this pie iron is perfect for sandwiches or toasting bread. The long handle, made of wood, ensures your hands are safe from the fire. It’s made of heavy-duty cast iron that ensures even heat distribution and excellent heat retention. Plus, it’s easy to clean, making it an ideal choice for outdoor cooking.
Specifications:
- Blade Material: Cast Iron
- Handle Material: Wood
- Weight: 3.5 pounds
Tested Features:
- Pre-seasoned cast iron construction for immediate use.
- Long wooden handle for safe handling.
- Easy to clean and maintain.
| Pros | Cons |
| – Comes pre-seasoned for immediate use – Durable and sturdy construction – Excellent heat distribution and retention | – Weight might be an issue for some due to the heavy-duty cast iron |
5. Rome’s Round Pie Iron
Last but not least, we have Rome’s Round Pie Iron. This pie iron stands out with its round design, offering a unique twist to your campfire pies. Manufactured by Rome Industries, it guarantees quality and durability, making your camping culinary experiences a delight.
Rome’s Round Pie Iron is perfect for those who like a traditional round pie. The cast iron construction ensures even heat distribution and excellent heat retention. The long handle, made of wood, keeps your hands safe from the fire. Plus, it’s easy to clean and maintain, making it a fantastic choice for your camping trips.
Specifications:
- Blade Material: Cast Iron
- Handle Material: Wood
- Weight: 3.35 pounds
Tested Features:
- Unique round design for traditional round pies.
- Durable cast iron construction for even cooking.
- Long wooden handle for safe handling.
| Pros | Cons |
| – Unique round design – Durable and sturdy construction – Excellent heat distribution and retention | – The round design might require some practice to perfect the pie shape. |
What to Look for When Choosing a Pie Iron for Camping?
- Material: Choose between cast iron and aluminum based on your preference for heat retention and weight.
- Design: Look for a design that suits your cooking style – whether you prefer a traditional round pie or a square one.
- Handle: Ensure it has a long handle to keep your hands safe from the heat.
- Weight: If you’re going to be hiking with your pie iron, consider its weight. Cast iron is heavier than aluminum.
- Ease of Use: Look for a pie iron that opens and closes easily and is simple to clean.
How to Use a Pie Iron for Camping?
- Preheat the pie iron over the fire before placing your ingredients inside.
- Use butter or oil on the inside of the pie iron to prevent sticking.
- Place your bread and filling inside, close the pie iron, and place it over the fire.
- Cooking times will vary depending on the heat of the fire and the type of filling. It’s usually wise to check after a few minutes.
- Use oven mitts or a thick cloth to open the pie iron as it will be very hot.
Comparison of Products
| Product | Material | Weight | Design |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rome Industries 1705 Pie Iron Sandwich Cooker | Cast Iron | 3.15 pounds | Square |
| Field & Stream Square Pie Iron | Cast Iron | 3.5 pounds | Square |
| Coghlan’s Cast Iron Camp Cooker | Cast Iron | 3.07 pounds | Double-clamp |
| Texsport Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Square Pie Iron | Cast Iron | 3.5 pounds | Square |
| Rome’s Round Pie Iron | Cast Iron | 3.35 pounds | Round |
Conclusion
And there you have it, folks! Your culinary camping game is about to level up with these top pie irons for camping in 2024. Remember, the best pie iron is the one that suits your needs and enhances your camping experience. So, whether you’re a fan of the traditional round pie or prefer a square one, there’s a pie iron out there with your name on it. Happy camping and even happier cooking!
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a pie iron on a regular stove?
While pie irons are designed for use over a campfire, they can also be used on a regular stove or a grill. Just be sure to use a heat-resistant glove or mitt when handling it.
How long does it take to cook a pie in a pie iron?
The cooking time varies depending on the intensity of the heat and the type of filling you are using. However, it usually takes around 5-10 minutes to cook a pie in a pie iron.
Do I need to season my pie iron?
Yes, it’s recommended to season your pie iron before the first use, especially if it’s made of cast iron. This process helps prevent rust and creates a non-stick surface.
Can I use a pie iron in a fire pit?
Absolutely! Pie irons are perfect for cooking over a fire pit, making them a great addition to backyard gatherings as well as camping trips.
Do I need to clean my pie iron after each use?
Yes, it’s important to clean your pie iron after each use to prevent food residue from sticking and burning onto the iron the next time you use it.
Deeba & Matt
About the Authors
Intrepid content creators and relentless hiking enthusiasts. With a passion for travel and adventure, Matt & Deeba are never one to shy away from a daring challenge.